When a tenant doesn’t pay, lease option versus land contract: eviction vs foreclosure.

by | Indy Anna, Real Estate Investing, Uncategorized

What happens when a tenant doesn’t pay?  When a tenant doesn’t pay with a lease option versus a land contract: eviction vs foreclosure.

First of all, THANK YOU again for making this channel the number one channel for Indiana real estate on YouTube according google analytics and SocialBlade info for BigReia.com.

This is a quick video I made about  a question that came in about dealing with a problem tenant.

Why is it harder to evict someone in a
land contract vs a lease with option?

Here’s the question:

“I’ve heard it’s more difficult to evict someone in a land contract than a lease with option.  Is that true and if so, why?”

It is true, and we are going to cover this in our class today.

While a land contract and a lease option (or a Master Lease or something like that) are both/all tools used to purchase a property based on some kind of seller financing, they are not equal.

Remember there is a hierarchy here are seven different levels of real estate ownership and/or control from weakest to strongest:

Get the Deed.  (something like a “subject to” deal)

Land Contract.  (this is recorded and provides “equity”)

Master Lease with Option.  (this can be a lease option for example)

Master Lease with Sublet.  (this allows you to rent out the property)

Short Term Rental Sublet.  (for deals like Air-BNB and other mini-rentals)

Standard Option.  (not something you will usually use by itself or in general)

Assignable Offer.  (like an option that you can assign or for wholesaling deals)

So today we are comparing the foreclosing on a Land Contract
versus the eviction with a Lease Option…

This example could be a master lease option or a master lease with sublet or any other combination.  The point is that when there are issues and you need to remove somebody from the property you need to have a good reason and a good plan to move forward. 

So a land contract (which can also be called a “Contract for Deed”) is a stronger ownership/control position than a lease option.  The land contract is more legally official or binding.  Meaning that although these methods are used to purchase a property based on the idea of seller financing, one is more official or binding than the other legally.

With a lease option…

This is a contract, yes… BUT…

The title is not able to be insured or the sale of the property officially recorded.  This is a lease, and while it’s structured differently than a rental, it is still a lease scenario.  Then the end terms come into play.

The formal eviction process:

After non-payment with a lease option, the formal eviction process will need to begin.  We have a class filing eviction that I already did so you can check that out for more on the eviction process.

Now for a land contract:

In a land contract, if the buyer/tenant doesn’t pay then this will require much more than the formal eviction process because there will be a foreclosure process that must begin after nonpayment. 

Why a “foreclosure”?

Because this is a hybrid recorded sale.  So the foreclosure process will need to happen and the judgment from the court will be necessary.  This will be a civil case, where the defendant (buyer) will be able to defend themselves. 

Will the buyers actually fight you in court?

The buyers or defendants rarely go to the trouble of appearing in court to contest their foreclosures.  The buyers are more likely to show up in court and fight when the plaintiff is an owner, investor or some other individual as opposed to a bank.

After the due process of foreclosure proceedings, the court will either rule a judgment in the owner or buyer’s interest in the land (property).  This can lead to a few different outcomes, in forms of back due payments being made, eviction taking place, etc.

One alternative to this is contract forfeiture.

This would simply be a forfeit of the contract by the buyer and it would be returned to the seller. 

This may not be upheld in all states for two reasons:

First, more states are becoming sympathetic to buyers left homeless or at least kicked out of a house by contract sales they are unable to afford.  As a result the rulings are often in the buyer’s favor.

Second, (goes along with No. 1), they buyer could lose a lot of money.  This would depend on how much money was put down and already paid over time.  The concern is that this would become a matter of the buyer being ‘forced’ out after significant investment.

The best ways to avoid having to go through a foreclosure and/or eviction:

You always want to require a big down payment, this helps qualify and commit buyers.  You also want to screen your buyers better and help them qualify so that they can follow through and purchase. 

The MOST important step is building and nurturing a great relationship with your buyers.  Many times they will not end up getting financing or buy the house so with a good relationship you can always help them make the best decision regardless of what it means for your house.

Build solid relationships and everything will go well… or at least better.

So those are the basics of a land contract versus a lease option having to evict a buyer tenant versus foreclosing on one.

Here are some legal contracts and paperwork you can download for FREE.

Here is a Land Contract Template.

Here is Eviction Notice that may be required to be sent X days before a hearing is scheduled.  It may also be required to issue as a preliminary to a foreclosure as well.

Here is a Breach of Contract template that can be filed on any contract issue in general.

Here is a Eviction for Non-Compliance that is sometimes necessary or helpful as you outline the specific reason they were required to vacate.

Here is a an Eviction Notice to Quit this is also a “Notice to Vacate Due to Late Rent” and sometimes this can be used with both a lease and/or contract.

You want to have as much legal documentation as possible.

This is why you train your Legal Eagle Team on exactly how they are to execute and perform.  This is also why you want to build a great relationship with your buyer and all of your people. 

Combine a good relationship with the fact that they see how seriously you track and document and everything and you should proactively avoid problems.

Thanks so much!  = )

Want more (brilliantly) EPIC posts of real estate investing and bidness badasssery...?

There is a great post and class on the 38 Ways to Buy Apartment Buildings Zero Down with Pet Policies, and here are some other helpful and EPIC posts... for starters as a real estate investor if you ever want to build a business that makes you 30 grand a month then you MUST do this...

The post is HERE.  There’s also another great class on how to buy apartment buildings zero down that you can check out as well.  This relates directly to growing income on rental properties.  Speaking of which make sure to check out our epic page on 14 ways to avoid tenants from hell.

Also here is a post on how I did this and I flipped a house off Zillow for 30.  Also you can check out the post on five steps to flip a house right off Zillow for 40.  You can also check out our other epic post on 57 ways to make money with vacant land.

Here’s another post on how a Hero flipped a house off Zillow and made 40k in a few weeks while he was learning to read.  Also you want to check our post on the EPIC $25 million letter and the copy writing lessons for real estate investors, you'll love it.  Also you can see how ONE letter is making me $9,000 a month.  Also you can check out the post on 101 FREE places to advertise your houses.

Also check out the "SA" class and your REAL chances of create social mobility and income ascension with your real estate business.  Brilliant stuff.  Also there is a great post on the ONLY way you'll ever make 30 grand a month as a real estate investor and/or business builder.  Another brilliant class with a free downloadable Investor Guide is about 19 Ways to Make $10,000 a Month by Helping Tired Landlords.

Plus make sure you check out Azam's post on how to hire a realtor that makes you $10,000 a month... while you sit back with your shoes kicked up on your desk and fingers folded behind your head.  Also there is a great post on how to make five grand a week from putting out signs.

Also we have some great posts on 30 ways to buy real estate with no money down.  That is a two part series so make sure to watch the second part on the 30 ways to buy real estate zero down and with no loans or credit.  I also get questions about our "Epic Flipping" and how to turn $1 into over $25,000 by flipping ordinary items for exponentially high ROI.

And don’t forget our EPIC page on 100 FREE ways to find motivated sellers, we are making the number one page in the world on FREE ways of finding motivated sellers.  Also check out how I find motivated sellers from code violation properties, and also how I make over $1,500 a week giving investors access to that list.

Go to BigReia.com and you’ll become allergic to being an LC and addicted to improving the world and creating Social Mobility for you and yours… 

Thanks so much!  = )

Make the Universe Smile.

~ Indy Anna
Love (at) BigReia.com
(317)969-5619 (that’s my Direct Line and and yes I actually answer lol)

Free Comic Book Reveals:

100 FREE ways to find motivated sellers.